"Which of these three beings is thinking, 'Yum. These oats are going to taste great next fall?'" Image via Wikipedia
We are NOT like the animals. Please don’t clump me with worms, dolphins, cats, monkeys, aphids, and even dogs! While watching a documentary on dolphin slaughter in Japan (23,000/year in one bay!), (http://www.savejapandolphins.org/), people equated dolphins with humans almost 20 times! Yes, we overlap in some behaviors, but please don’t equate animals and humans. Here’s why…
In Ecclesiastes 3, verses 18-21 Solomon says that, yes, we are like the animals because they live and die and so do we. They breathe. We breathe. We have similar functions, and then we die. In verse 19, he states that this is HEBEL, a misty, transient, temporary, and “crappy” condition of our life on earth. We are both doomed to die. We have no choice in the matter at all!
21 Who knows if the spirit of man rises upward and if the spirit of the animal goes down into the earth?”
Some people have taken this verse out of context to say that humans and animals both have “spirits”. They make this verse say too much. Solomon simply states the obvious: When a person or animal dies, we don’t see a “ghosty” cloud leaving the body going up or down. You can believe what you want about dogs or animals in heaven, but that is not what is being said here. We humans cannot see beyond this life. We cannot see spiritual things with our eyes. What can we see?
22 So I saw that there is nothing better for a man than to enjoy his work, because that is his lot. For who can bring him to see what will happen after him?
Solomon sees a powerful, life-giving force at work when someone enjoys working (producing results). Animals don’t work and find meaning. An oxen plowing a field has no greater satisfaction at the end of the day. A dog doesn’t lick itself, and say, “I love the feeling of being clean!” A horse doesn’t think when plowing and say, “Yum! These oats are going to taste great next fall!” They don’t find satisfaction in labor like humans do! Only humans are given that “lot in life.” That is our place! Enjoyment is what distinguishes humans from animals.
Humans CAN act like animals! Humans CAN act animal-ish, ruled by impulse, desires, and basal bodily functions. Humans CAN ignore the ultimate questions of why we do what we do, what happens after life, why are we here, how do we find real pleasure, how do we know God exists. The brilliance of Solomon’s wisdom is in asking the question in verse 22, “Who can bring him to see what will happen after him?” He begs the greatest question, “Where is God in this world?”
God is within this world, a good God, a God that wants our happiness in an unjust world, who can make work meaningful because he is present in it somehow. He asks us to think less like an animal and ultimately to acknowledge his presence! No animal can do that!
